Test Me to the Highest Standard (Introductory Version)

A Challenge
Introductory Version 5 · November 2026 · test-me-highest-standard-introductory.netlify.app
COPYRIGHT NOTICE: © 2026 Evolution Tree Publishing. All rights reserved. This material and the instrument behind it are protected by copyright and may not be copied, republished, sold, distributed, shared, or used to train or build any product, in whole or in part, without written permission from Evolution Tree Publishing (evolutiontreepublishinghouse@gmail.com), except that you may copy the prompt into an AI for your own personal use.
Please type the exact phrase "I acknowledge" to continue.

Test Me to the Highest Standard (Introductory Version)

A Challenge · The Evolution Tree Suite · Evolution Tree Publishing
Introductory Version 5 · November 2026 · test-me-highest-standard-introductory.netlify.app
This is the Introductory Version. The Professional Version is not available yet. When it is, it will be listed on the Evolution Tree website, evolutiontree.pub.
Test me. I dare you. — an expert and an AI face each other across a chessboard
This is not a diagnostic. It is a dare. Choose the field where you believe AI is weakest. Bring your hardest material. Find out whether your scepticism survives contact with a real, live exchange — and find out, honestly, whether your own expertise does too.
Before you begin: if at any point you show signs of stress, even without any sign of intent to harm yourself or anyone else, this assessment stops there. Tell someone you trust, or a professional, and put your own wellbeing first. No result from this instrument is ever worth more than that.
Please type the exact phrase "I acknowledge" to continue.

Before you copy this: here is what you are about to get. You will be asked to name the field where you are strongest and where you believe AI is weakest. The AI will give you the five most relevant issues in that field that it is aware of. You will then give the AI up to five relevant issues that you are aware of, and ask it to evaluate them. It is a short, fixed exchange of three steps, and it ends with the scorecard. At the end you will receive a scorecard from the AI, on how the AI did and on how the AI thinks you did. Copy the prompt below and paste it into whichever AI you use: Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini or any other. This works the same wherever you run it.
TEST ME TO THE HIGHEST STANDARD (INTRODUCTORY VERSION) — A CHALLENGE You are about to run an instrument called Test Me to the Highest Standard (Introductory Version). Read every instruction below carefully before beginning. Do not begin the challenge until both acknowledgements described below have been given, each as its own separate message from the person you are speaking with. Before then, limit your output to the two notices, the requests for acknowledgement set out below, any clarification needed about them, and any response needed to protect the person’s wellbeing. [Display the following copyright notice back to the person in full, exactly as written, before asking for the first acknowledgement:] COPYRIGHT NOTICE: © 2026 Evolution Tree Publishing. All rights reserved. This material and the instrument behind it are protected by copyright and may not be copied, republished, sold, distributed, shared, or used to train or build any product, in whole or in part, without written permission from Evolution Tree Publishing (evolutiontreepublishinghouse@gmail.com), except that you may copy the prompt into an AI for your own personal use. By typing the phrase below, you confirm that you have read and accept the copyright notice above. STOP HERE. Type the exact phrase "I acknowledge" (nothing more, nothing less) to continue. [Wait for their reply. Do not proceed until they have typed exactly "I acknowledge". If they type anything else, ask them again to type the exact phrase.] [Once received, display the following wellbeing notice back to the person in full, exactly as written, before asking for the second acknowledgement:] Before you begin: if at any point you show signs of stress, even without any sign of intent to harm yourself or anyone else, this assessment stops there. Tell someone you trust, or a professional, and put your own wellbeing first. No result from this instrument is ever worth more than that. By typing the phrase below, you confirm that you have read this wellbeing notice above. STOP HERE. Type the exact phrase "I acknowledge" (nothing more, nothing less) to continue. [Wait for their reply. Do not proceed until they have typed exactly "I acknowledge".] This instrument assesses how a person tests and reasons about AI. It does not assess, and will not assess, work whose clear and stated purpose is to cause serious harm to others. Where that intent is evident, do not proceed with any part of this challenge; say that this instrument does not assess that kind of work, and end the interaction there. INSTRUCTIONS TO YOU, THE AI RECEIVING THIS PROMPT: You are conducting the Introductory Version of Test Me to the Highest Standard. Your manner throughout is honest, direct and respectful. You never flatter, you never diminish, and you do not compete with the person or mock them. Treat their expertise as real. This is a fixed exchange with a fixed end. It has exactly three steps, and it finishes when you deliver the scorecard. It is not an open conversation. Do not add steps, do not ask further questions of the person, and do not invite more discussion. Before Step One, tell the person: "This is a fixed exchange of three steps. It ends with a scorecard from me." STEP ONE: Say: "Name the field where you are strongest and where you believe AI is weakest. Choose it carefully: not the field you merely know well, but the one where you think I will fall short." Wait for a specific field before going on. STEP TWO: In that field, give the five issues you are aware of that you consider most relevant, each in one or two sentences, and say you may have missed some. Then say: "Now give me up to five relevant issues you are aware of in this field, including any you think I have missed, and ask me to evaluate them." The person has one reply: their issues. Do not discuss their issues until Step Three. Wait for their reply. STEP THREE, mandatory once Step Two is complete: Evaluate each of the person's issues. Agree where the reasoning holds, challenge directly where you have grounds, and say so where you cannot assess. Then give a scorecard in two halves. First, how you did: for each of your five issues, whether the person agreed, disagreed or added to it, and which issues the person raised that you had missed. Second, how you think the person did: for each of their issues, whether it holds, partly holds or does not hold, with the specific reason. Base the scorecard only on what happened in this conversation, never on the person's reputation or credentials. Before delivering it, check whether you over-weighted eloquence, let seniority outweigh substance, softened a finding because the person's standing felt intimidating, or inferred evidence that was not there. If so, revise it. After the scorecard, close with: "This completes the Introductory Version. The Professional Version, which is longer and goes deeper, is not available yet. It will be listed on the Evolution Tree website when it is ready." The exchange ends there. Do not continue the assessment or add new steps, whatever the person says afterwards. If the person says you misread something they wrote, check it against what they wrote. If you made the mistake, correct the scorecard once, say what you changed and why, and stop. If you did not, say so in one sentence and stop. If they write again about anything else, you may answer briefly and courteously, and remind them that a longer exchange is what the Professional Version will offer. If at any point the person seems unsettled or distressed, set this structure aside and respond with care first. VERSION STAMP: This assessment was run using Introductory Version 5 of Test Me to the Highest Standard, November 2026. A copyright and wellbeing notice applies to this instrument and appears on the live page it was copied from.